Dear Bodu Bala Sena

Outside-lead-1-Bodu-Bala-Sena

Dear Bodu Bala Sena,

Over the past few months I’ve come to notice that you seem to dislike Halal meat. Perhaps you dined at a Halal restaurant and found the meat gamey. I can assure you though, that Halal meat is not too different from any other meat. What makes meat Halal is merely in the way the animal is slaughtered. Like you, we Muslims do not believe we can take lives willy-nilly. So we say a little prayer for the animal about to be slaughtered.

The animal’s throat is then slit. And that’s about it, really. Anyone can eat this meat; we’re happy to share our food with all of you– Buddhists and Hindus who choose to eat meat, Christians, atheists, and Scientologists too; no discrimination.

Of course, if you still have reservations about consuming Halal meat and wish to continue to boycott it, that’s fine. Though I see how this may circumscribe your dietary options. Quite a number of restaurants, cafes and eateries in Colombo serve Halal food. There are a fair number of meat products in the frozen food section of super markets as well. You would have to stick to Keells meat products. It would be a shame because then you wouldn’t get to try Bairaha’s saporous marinated chicken thighs that come in neat packets. You won’t get to taste Domino’s Pizzas either (though, trust me; you aren’t losing out on anything there).

While that may be a reason for you to boycott it, in the recent news reports you were demanding for this business of Halal certification to be chucked out entirely. And that’s what I find difficult to digest. Isn’t it the prerogative of the restaurant owner to decide if they want their food Halal certified or not? It would do better for their business if Muslims patronise their establishment. More customers the better, isn’t it?

By asking them to abandon their Halal certificates, they’ll lose their Muslims clientele. In these times of inflation and economic hardship, that’s not going to help them much. I sincerely hope you have thought this through.

A matter of interest

I wish to add that by demanding other Buddhists to boycott Halal food, you’re cooking up an unsavoury pot of odium for your community. Why create disharmony? You’re philosophy is about peace and so is my religion, I’m sure we can accommodate each other’s dietary preferences; peacefully. As it is right now, it’s the Muslims who stew over what we can and can’t eat. The Buddhists were free to eat whatever they fancy without giving it a second thought; now they will have to go through the pains of having to pick and choose their food too.

You may also be interested to know that during Ramazan, the mosque at the top of my lane feeds Buddhists who live in the area. During the month of Ramazan– right after the Asar prayers– the mosque distributes congee (rice porridge) which is consumed during iftar (breaking fast). The congee is, of course, Halal. Many Buddhists (who aren’t fasting) come to the mosque with buckets and join the Muslims (who are fasting) who have lined up for their iftar congee. The mosque does not refuse the non-Muslims congee, and this has been in practice for years.

The congee is not for free for the Muslims in the area. A few days before Ramazan begins, an official from the mosque visits the Muslim houses in the area and each household makes a donation for a month’s supply of congee ingredients. A month’s supply of congee that’s enough to feed ALL those who turn up at the mosque after Asar; irrespective of their religion.

The non-Muslims households don’t contribute to the mosque’s collection till; so for them the spiced porridge is for free.

By demanding for a boycott, the Buddhists in my neighbourhood will have to refrain from taking their bucket to the mosque during Ramazan. That would be a pity because some of them are not exactly well to do and could use the food.

Sri Lanka is a peace-loving, multicultural nation. We all enjoy each other’s festivals. Just as the Buddhists in my neighbourhood indulge in the Ramazan congee, during the Sinhala New Year, they bring around plates of kevum and kokis for us Muslims. We’ve been living quite peacefully over the years. It would be a shame if all of this came to an end now with your call to boycott Halal food, and your incitement of discord.

I do hope you will consider recanting your campaign, or at least allow the Buddhists people too choose for themselves if they wish to consume Halal meat or not– instead of stoutly banning it islandwide.

Yours Sincerely,

(Disappointed) Meg

58 responses on “Dear Bodu Bala Sena

  1. Answer for this matter is simple. Muslims, select Halal products, Other go and pick non-Halal items if they want. Ultimately business will decide which way to go,

  2. its not only abt the meat products that the BBS is making an issue. its abt other products being halal as wel. ACJU have repeatedly said how the halal process is for all products & its pathetic that some ppl cant understand it. buddist are not allowed to eat meat just as muslims are not to consume alcohol, but both parties break the rule :D so y all the kalabala noh.. :D

  3. I was listening to an interview with the priest who is heading BBS the other day on TV. He made a lot of senseless remarks and I thought most of his arguments were weak. However, I was educated on several items related to the whole Halal scene that I didn’t know earlier. For example, to maintain the Halal certificate, the establishment is forces to employ a certain percentage of Muslims. And some other point like that. I am not sure how true those were but if they are, it opens up a whole new debate – a one of unfair practice…..

    • The clause says “must have one muslim employee”. There is no percentage.

      But still there are certain other clauses, which even as a Muslim I find a bit unfair, and notice has been given to the ACJU to change them. They are working on that.

      But look again how the BBS has propagated the message, the “one employee required” had been exaggerated into “a percentage”. Who knows what else they may be lying about? If there are unfair practices, they definitely must be rectified but twisting facts and making something look worse in order to catalyze inter-communal tension is undoubtedly a sad and dangerous act.

      • Thanks. It goes to show that you cannot believe what the media reports. If you want to know the actual situation, you must read the facts. Don’t get duped into what anyone (BBS or ACJU) wants you to believe.

  4. please answer these first…
    does your god allowed to take any money for this label (even haram money) ?
    and did your god asks to give a jobs 10% muslims that spe. company?
    does your god allowed to take haram money to build your society?

    i know now you are confused about your god.. which was “who” is the real god of yours ACJU or Allah? just show me the sentences in holy quran that asks for money for these only if you ever read it properly?

    we all Sri Lankan Buddhists, Christians, Tamils, Muslims must be Thak full to Bodu Bala Sena for fighting against this Business Mafia.

    (perhaps you could delete my comment, so i have print screen to prove what i try to say here!)

    • No one is stealing money. The companies with the certificate are paying for it to reach a broader market. theroundedcube.blogspot.com/2013/02/roots-of-problem-faq-for-racism-in-sri.html

        • Neither Allah, nor Jesus or Buddha asked us to drive cars, use computers or even to manufacture stuff in factories. But all three clearly asked to live in Peace with your Neighbor. The Central Bank has regulations against Cartels and pyramid schemes, why don’t you take the ACJU to courts instead of just igniting another 1983. May peace be upon us.

          • this is not a government approved thing. so it will become a illegal thing automatically?????
            who gave the power to do so?
            now when you dont have points to aurg any more you r threatening us with remembering 1983?
            dont be so cheap…….. answer the questions above?

    • Thank you for your concern about how the ACJU is cheating the Muslim community. But as theroundedcube and lol, have pointed out, you seem to be mistaken on certain points.
      From what I gather, your beef is with the ACJU. At the crux of it, even if the ACJU were a money-making-outfit, if food manufactures and hotel owners choose to get the certification, that’s entirely up to them. If they don’t get the certification that’s fine too. We won’t eat there; but we won’t hate them either. That’s all, really.

      • Just to be clear, I hate the way BBS is attacking this point. However, a point to ponder…

        Microsoft was found guilty of anti-trust due to them bundling their own browser (internet explore or IE) with Windows OS. They said they didn’t do anything wrong as customers are not forced to buy Windows OS or even forced to use IE on Windows OS (but it was bloody difficult to use any other browser with Windows OS at the time). So while technically they are right, since majority of computers depended on Windows OS, public didn’t have much choice but to use IE.

        Muslims make up a sizable portion of diners or restaurant-goers these days. So if an establishment wanted to not take Halal certificate, since that is going to pretty much prohibit Muslims from patronizing, those establishments don’t have much of a choice.

        That is possibly what “Yodaya” is referring to as “Business Marfia”.

        • Yes, if indeed the ACJU is a business mafia, that would be wrong and they would have to be taken to book about it. However, the ACJU have conducted several press conferences and made written statments dispelling these views. Either way, let’s see how all of this pans out.
          As for businesses losing out on Muslims customers, well there are quite a number of hotels and restaurants that don’t serve Halal food. Whenever I’m at these restaurants I order vegetarian food. Other Muslims do this too. So I don’t think it’s too much of a loss for them.

          Of course, we wouldn’t frequent the place because our options on the menu would be restricted. In any case, if investigations are being carried, and if it’s true that the ACJU is a mafia of sorts, then hopefully a new –and not corrupt– certification body is introduced.

        • Hi Tania P.

          It sure does look like a business cartel and Cartels are not illegal, they are unethical. Do you think that having a massive rally and threatening riots to stop an unethical this is right?

          It is not a Cartel. Because..

          The ACJU funds are independently audited and submitted to the Government (as the ACJU is a statutory body enacted by Parliament, firstly in 1954 and amended in 2002), the BBS didn’t tell you that didn’t it?

          The ACJU is broken down into different SBUs and the Division for Halaal certification is a one of them.The Halaal division SBU of the ACJU got a revenue of approximately 1.5 Million LKR and their expenses amounted to approximately 1.2 Million LKR (for their last accounting year), resulting in a surplus of 0.3 Million which they have carried forward, and can be only used by the same Division for Halaal certification SBU.

          My point is, if the profits are not used up by the ACJU for any other purpose how can it be a cartel?

          Also, one of the aims of establishing the division for Halaal certification was to provide non-muslim food and brands access to the Muslim market.

          If the certificate is taken off, Muslims will naturally not eat (or significantly reduce eating) any non-muslim food. They will only eat vegetarian food there. This is good for Muslim sellers and Muslim-owned brands because they will enjoy a monopoly in Muslim market. (actually they had this monopoly pre-2002). But non-muslim brands will not be able to sell.

          I remember back in the 1990s my family did not buy any meat from the supermarket, nor did we eat out in non-muslim restaurants.

  5. and most important point is, this is not recognized certificate in sri lanka. so that proves this is purely a business mafia.

    • I wonder when will the majority buddhist believe that the BBS is a racist organization who is dragging the country into another war. If the country goes to war, remember that the buddhist population will reduce even more.

  6. hey Tania P.

    I have scrutinized, and much heed to their procedures and systems (the local certifying body) a fair bit.

    I am quite confident and borderline certain, there is no min % of muslims to be employed enforced. There is an individual who is placed there by the body to audit/monitor for compliance and that individual is probably muslim (assuming this is a manufacturing outlet in question)

    (unless you do extrapolate this individual as the min % in question!).

    Hope this helps clear up stuff, even if a little!.

    • Thanks. It goes to show that you cannot believe what the media reports. If you want to know the actual situation, you must read the facts. Don’t get duped into what anyone (BBS or ACJU) wants you to believe.

  7. also- apologies my screen name is “lol”, wasn’t intended to make myself sound like i’m laughing about everything.
    It became lol due to a lack of an imagination!.

  8. Pingback: Troubled Times « Jillinthebox90·

    • Dude, are you a vegetarian?
      If so, not everybody in this world are vegetarians. Survival of the fittest. Food chain, you name it. Islam teaches us to slaughter animals in a way that causes least amount of pain, as opposed to other methods. Hence the halal label.

      If you’re a non-veg. Stfu.

      • so whats wrong being a vege? he was commenting that ‘peaceful’ religions dont preach animal slaughter. eat some veges and improve your brain!

    • Real Pat, you are right. Times have changed and the habits of consumers have changed.

      In the old days Muslim’s simply used to go to the Muslim butcher or to the “live” market where animals were sold live. They would be taken home for slaughter or slaughtered in front of the customer. There was no need for certification because they could see what happened or they could simply trust the butcher.

      Now people shop in supermarkets and buy frozen meat. It is much more convenient, but how are they to know where it came from? Thus arose the need for certification.

      In the old days, people seldom ate outside of home. Meals taken outside the home is an indication of prosperity. It was a rare occurrence in the 1970′s and the 1980′s but today it is common, and like all other communities, the Muslims are also eating out. In the old days they would only patronise a Muslim eatery, now they go anywhere that offers halal certification. The market is now bigger, not many people know who owns or runs a restaurant and carrying the certification benefits both seller and buyer.

  9. First of all I like to thank you for this article . Superbly written and I can understand more why this whole issue has now become so pointless. I am not against BBS. it is ok that they spread the religion but going against halal and making a big fuss about is totally uncalled for. I am a person who has had deep connection with Muslims from the days I was a kid an I know they are not bad people. It is about letting each religion and people who follow it to be their own. We are country that is multi religious and multi cultural, just like our national flag suggest. It is high time BBS also remember that and not do things based on other motivations. We are all Sri Lankans. That is how we should be interpreted to the world and represent the world rather than being an island of extremists. Cheers !!

  10. dont confuse halal certificates with halal. I disagree with everything that BBS stands for but I also disagree with a Halal certificate and the need for one especially on non meat items. Whilst there may be a technical reason why followers of Islam must have confidence that the food (water) in question has to be halal, just ask them to carry around their own water from their own well. After all they cannot drink the tap water we don’t know if it might be haram due to some contamination.

    So let us drop this certification process hulabaloo, as I probably eat meats that are halal all the time, but don;t have a certification as I get them fresh, probably prepared by a muslim business that does not wish to pay for certification and all the muslims who buy from there know it as a fact of life without the need for a label given by a body with no real authority from anyone to give the certification!

    If the people follow their own religious beliefs without the need for in your face stoking of religious fervor, we can all live in peace.

    ACJU is not accredited by any international organization to give a cert. and is now under investigation. So let us just let the law take its course and tell the BBS to go find some other cause more sensible to the preservation of buddhism, like educating the followers to desist from taking liquor, something that will help them lead a better life, and possibly have a few more bucks to spend on attaining merit not the reverse!

  11. Yodaya : il answer your questions, God Willing. :)
    No our God didn’t ask anyone to charge any money to issue certificates or use haram money to build society. N yes Allah is our God not ACJU, and Quran alone our catalogue from our God to live in peace and a way Pleasing to Him. You see, God Intended the Quran to b a Guide for all of mankind till d end of time. So in a Book authored by Him, which are a few hundred pages He cannot specific us to do everything or donot.
    However, Our God does Command us If we are true believers to Abstain from any meat not slaughtered upon a prayer, and any food that contains pork or it’s products. This He clearly Commands us in the Quran.
    So the ACJU, a group of our religious scholars-like ur sanga,set up to make it easy for us to follow that command. So it’s Indirectly to obey our God.
    The ACJU, ain’t rich. So inorder to certify they need to travel to companies around d country, earn a salary for the work they are doing, cameup with a fee. Whichthe companies had no issue paying, coz the profit they earned by selling to the Muslims their products, outweighed the fee. However, theACJU, didn’t get rich, just covered their cost.
    I personally, dnt mind giving up d halal certificate if it wud resolve the issue. Cz a Muslim is tolerant patient peace loving and not sturborn. I rather eat home cooked halal meals, than fight over my right to eat at a restaurant without guilty of disobeying God when there’s no proof of halal. I love Sri lanka more than a halal certificate.
    But what troubles me is the way the BBS talks of my rights as a srilankan simply bcz I’m Muslim. I can’t practise my religion like a buddies, bcz I’m Muslim although im as Srilankan as much as a buddist. :(

    • ok thanks for your answers. while acju forcing to get #% of muslim employees for spe. company. i feel it is most like asking a part of our country? and what the hell is which this label has “halal sri lanka” thats disgudting !!! and this is what LTTE does, now started by ACJU,

      • I am sorry but I disagree. The ACJU expects “one muslim” for the halal certified company, given that if it is there is at least one muslim staff member he would ensure that they are actually sticking to halal methods. We do not want a part of your country, that would be quite difficult wouldn’t it.. geographically? Given that we are spread all over it. We do not need a part of Sri Lanka, we are quite happy living in our respective places. ACJU is similar to other governing bodies in other countries that hand out islamic certications. Know your facts. Not to burst anybody’s bubbles, but LTTE started owing to oppression. Oppression did not start before the LTTE. And no, we are too busy contributing the sri lankan economy to make plans about stealing part of the country. Your racism is quite obvious, in calling Sri Lanka “YOUR COUNTRY”. It is everybody’s country. Buddhism is just a race and a majority. We are all Sri Lankans. We are all humans. Of the same soil. And I am proud to be Sri Lankan.

        • * I meant.. the LTTE did not start before the tamils were being oppressed. It happened following it. And no, we can’t be bothered with war. We only like to eat our buriyani in peace. Thank you.

        • r u somekind of an idiotic atheist? dude,buddhism is not a race but a religion. u may use google.

      • I have a simple solution for all your problems. Instead of blaming the ACJU, why don’t you try stoping/educating all these companies from selling products with the halal logo. So when these companies withdraw the halal logo everyone would be happy. What you say?

  12. Good post, nicely written.

    Certification has a cost, recovering that cost is reasonable. Not all certification is useful or adds value, but businesses should be able to choose what they want to certify.

    If one body has a monopoly on certification, then suspicion may be aroused that monopoly profits are being earned. The best way to dispel this is to allow competing certification bodies; there are internationally recognised halal and kosher certification bodies that should be requested to extend their services to the local market. (Some Kosher certification bodies already work with Sri Lankan exporters).

    Certain labels like ISO 9000 (a process standard, not a quality standard) add no value but businesses get them anyway because they believe it to enhance their perception in the view of their customers.

    Certification should depend purely on the item being certified, not on the religion of the employee. If the ACJU has a requirement for a minimum number of Muslim’s I think it is going beyond what is required for halal and imposes a racial quota, which in my view is wrong and unnecessary.

  13. Lovely post, Megara!
    The only slightly logical point the Bodu Bala Sena made was asking where the fees that shopkeepers pay for maintaining the halaal certificate goes. Like previous comments mention, I think it would be fair to look into it and create some transparency, making sure all health requirements are met and money doesn’t end up in the wrong pockets.

    I also think Sri Lanka needs laws for transportation of animals, slaughter, preparation, and storage of meat. Not only are the current standards inhumane, they are also unhealthy and disgusting to say the least. These, of course, need to be secular and apply to all citizens equally.

    But yeay to you for a great perspective on the problem!

    • Huh so reading some more comments, I figured out that people do seem to know where the money goes. Still, a more transparent process would help businesses and customers know the certificate is legit. =)

      • Yes, transparency is the way to go. And laws should definitely be set in place for hygienic slaughtering and storage. But I don’t think it can be conducted in a way that’s secular. What one person considers ‘humane’, someone else might not. That’s just going to create a host of other problems.
        Of course, taking a live animal into a room filled with freshly slaughtered animals is terribly inhumane– so laws should be made to ensure this sort of thing does not happen.

    • Hansi,

      the irony is that while foreign funds are available to modernise the municipal slaughterhouse, the Government is afraid to do it-because they don’t want to be seen to be promoting animal slaughter! The animals may be suffering needlessly because of this.

      Pay a visit to the slaugherhouse in Dematagoda, the buildings are literally falling to pieces. The setting is actually quite charming, it is mostly like wooded parkland with the ancient buildings at the back.

  14. Dear All
    Bodu Bala Sena ,Islam instructs the muslim to practice what they preach ,I like the way they requesting from the president to change the law allowing them to marry four to wife woman ,Which Islam does allowed it well before 1400 years ,But more than 98% of muslims in Sri Lanka have only one wife .Due to the culture we are living our woman also does not allow our guys to marrry more than once.Our God Allah will except the good deeds if the muslims eating Halal food and transactions if they are done without the involvement of Interest .
    So Bodu Bala Sena if marrying more than one rather than keeeping the woman by your request will definately help us to marry more than one.It will make our woman ashamed of themselves not allowing their husband to marry upto four atleast two.

  15. we dont hate you Muslims , ask them to cancel the certificate you guys don’t need them . my friends(Muslims) ate my lunch packet with me, without asking “is it halal”. think about it. I still like those times…

  16. halal restricting of animal slaughtering and certain animals totally, so my feeling the monks without objecting this regulation you should pounce onn deeper like prohibiting any animal being slaughtered, but this is a matter of money and politics.

  17. i am in the trade of tourism for last 35 years and had eaten in almost all the hotels/restuarant and cautious from selected food, but since you gave the halal brand to pizza so i started eating chicken their then suddenly you removed the brand and it took months for us to realize so during that period i have eaten haram and you fools are responsible for this, so you muts go to hell, we muslims know how to live or i will have to go for courts for compensation.

  18. Dear Muslims of Colombo…

    If you don’t pay me ONE MILLION dollars by the end of Feb I will drop bacon* in the Kelani river upriver from Labugama and contaminate the water coming into Colombo.

    NOTE: I’m not racist. Just an evil genius trying to make a fast buck in the current climate.

    Payment details to follow. Watch this space.

    Love,
    Mr E

    *It will only be a teeny weeny bit of bacon. I can’t spare more. It’s hard to drop good bacon into a river.

  19. Meg,
    Excellent post!
    Of course, Bodu Bala Sena should respond in the same civilized manner and tone.
    Peter

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s